Nigel Biggar at Mayo Clinic

2 05 2012

Last month, Nigel Biggar was the keynote speaker for an event at the Mayo Clinic in Minnesota. In his lecture, Biggar discussed what it means for religious believers to engage with others on moral debates generally, as well as on specific matters related to medical ethics, such as abortion and euthanasia.

The event, entitled Why Religion Deserves a Place in Secular Medicine, was organized by the Veritas Forum and respondents included the Reverend Dan Hall of the University of Pittsburgh, and Professor Warren Kinghorn of Duke University Medical School. The full text of the lecture is available here.





New Book: Peter Singer & Christian Ethics

18 04 2012

Peter Singer and Christian EthicsThe first book to emerge from last year’s McDonald Centre conference on Peter Singer has just been published by Cambridge University Press.

Available from Amazon UK and Amazon USA.

No living philosopher is most controversial than Peter Singer. In this book, Charlie Camosy, who is currently Visiting Fellow at the McDonald Centre, offers a critical, but constructive reading of Singer’s arguments on animal rights, euthanasia, poverty, and abortion. He finds important and surprising areas of common ground between Singer and Christian ethics, but he also does not hold back in pressing Singer where his views are lacking. The book is a model of the McDonald Centre’s vision that Christians can in public engage generously, rigorously, and candidly, even with views that they do not share.

From the back cover:

Interaction between Peter Singer and Christian ethics, to the extent that it has happened at all, has been unproductive and often antagonistic. Singer sees himself as leading a ‘Copernican Revolution’ against a sanctity of life ethic, while many Christians associate his work with a ‘culture of death.’ Charles Camosy shows that this polarized understanding of the two positions is a mistake. While their conclusions about abortion and euthanasia may differ, there is surprising overlap in Christian and Singerite arguments, and disagreements are interesting and fruitful. Furthermore, it turns out that Christians and Singerites can even make common cause, for instance in matters such as global poverty and the dignity of non-human animals. Peter Singer and Christian ethics are far closer than almost anyone has imagined, and this book is valuable to those who are interested in fresh thinking about the relationship between religious and secular ethics.

More information is available from Cambridge University Press and Facebook. Camosy is a regular contributor to the blog, Catholic Moral Theology.





Making Medical Killing Legal

16 01 2012

Earlier this month, Lord Falconer’s Commission for Assisted Dying released a 400-page report advocating the legalization of assisted suicide in a narrow range of situations.  The report was commissioned by the campaign group Dignity in Dying. It describes the current law on assisted dying as “inadequate and incoherent” and offers a legal framework that would permit only those who had been diagnosed with less than a year to live to seek an assisted suicide, and then only if they met strict eligibility criteria. In the latest Parliamentary Brief, John Perry defends the law as it currently stands. He concludes:

The present system preserves both the integrity of the medical profession and the general prohibition of killing, but at the same time makes room for rare exceptions via the prosecutor’s discretion. That’s messy, imperfect—and probably just about right.

The Falconer Report was funded by the author Terry Pratchett. In the latest issue of Triple Helix, Dr Richard Hain offers this thoughtful review of Pratchett’s much-discussed BBC documentary, Choosing to Die.





Biggar & Singer Debate in Standpoint

7 07 2011

Following the recent conference, Standpoint magazine convened a dialogue between Peter Singer and Nigel Biggar. Hosted by Standpoint editor, Daniel Johnson, the conversation spans a variety of topics, including the value of human and animal life, the morality of killing, abortion, infanticide, euthanasia, and others.

Standpoint: We have just been attending a conference in Oxford entitled Christian Ethics Engages Peter Singer. Perhaps we should kick off with a question that you, Nigel, asked at the end of the conference. On what grounds, Peter, would you give greater weight to the interests, the preferences, theneeds of the Jewish victims in the Holocaust, rather than the Nazi perpetrators? …  Read the debate in full.





The Road to Death on Demand

1 03 2010

The new issue of Standpoint includes an article, featured on the magazine’s cover, by Nigel Biggar. It criticizes proposed changes to British law to permit physician assisted suicide. Visit the Standpoint site to read the article and join the discussion. For an in-depth study of the underlying moral and theological issues, see Biggar’s 2004 book, Aiming to Kill. The article was quoted by Dominic Lawson in last week’s Sunday Times.





Biggar on Intentional Medical Killing

17 11 2009

The question before us is whether the law should permit doctors to help patients kill themselves, or kill them at their request—that is, the question of the legalisation of physician-assisted suicide or voluntary euthanasia. In the UK, intentional medical killing is currently illegal, as is the case in most jurisdictions. But there are many people who think that the law should be changed, and attempts are frequently made to do so… Read the article in full








Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.